Opposition Pours In

This week was the perfect storm for opponents of the revised GBS with condemnation raining down on the flawed book grab from around the globe.

Thursday was the last day for public filings in opposition to the settlement and there was no shortage of opponents or different takes on why the GBS was destructive, unfair and beyond salvation.

Consumer groups were especially active with comments filed from Public Knowledge and Consumer Watchdog.  In its brief, Consumer Watchdog noted that not only is the settlement an unconstitutional attempt to revise copyright law, but it also continues to award Google an unlawful and anti-competitive monopoly.

From the author’s camp, filings were delivered to Judge Chin from the Science Fiction and Fantasy Writers of America and American Society of Journalists and Authors, Inc. Noted U.K. author and anti-GBS petition signer Ursula K. Le Guin also shared her case against the revised deal with the court.

And while the revised settlement cut out many non-english writing authors in an attempt to placate international objections to the deal – while also shattering the illusion of the library as being a representation of humanity’s knowledge – another round of objections sprang up from all corners of the globe.  Groups representing Japanese authors and Indian authors joined advocates from Germany, France, Italy and the U.K. in denouncing the plan.

We can only hope that Judge Chin and the settlement parties are listening to this overwhelming and varied outpouring of opposition.

  • It is filed under: Uncategorized
  • Tags:

Leave a reply

Learn more…

Connect and Follow


The mass digitization of books promises to bring tremendous value to consumers, libraries, scholars, and students. The Open Book Alliance will work to advance and protect this promise. And, by...


What Experts Are Saying About the Settlement…

Important Dates

December 14, 2009
Notice begins

January 28, 2010
Deadline for authors to opt out of the settlement

January 28, 2010
Deadline to file objections and/or amicus briefs

February 4, 2010
Deadline to file notice of intent to appear at Fairness Hearing

February 4, 2010
DOJ response

February 11, 2010
Plaintiffs move for final approval

February 18, 2010
Final Fairness Hearing

March 31, 2011
Deadline to claim Books and Inserts